November 28, 2016

Hanjin collapse is tip of iceberg in struggling shipping industry

The global shipping industry is in dire straits with international rates low for five years, and for some vessels, the current day rates are covering less than 5 per cent of costs.

South Korea's Hanjin shipping company collapsed in September, owing $8 billion in debt. It left 97 ships stranded around the world unable to pay for fuel or other fees, with $14 billion worth of goods stuck on board.

"These ships cost the shipowner about $18,000 a day to put to sea, some of them have been accepting day rates of $750 a day. They are losing money hand over fist," said Teresa Lloyd, chief executive of Maritime Industry Australia.

"This has been the longest and most sustained downturn in rates that any part of the industry has ever seen, it's absolutely dire at the moment."

In Australia, the Hanjin California was seized for a month in Sydney and the Hanjin Milano was stranded outside the Port of Melbourne. Woolworths, Big W, Masters and Pacific Brands all had goods tied up on those ships.

"Hanjin had been in financial difficulty since the GFC in 2008. There's an oversupply of vessels in the market," said Ryan Eagle, partner at Ferrier Hodgson.

"Hanjin had been loss making for a number of years, particularly the last 5 years."

With the stranded ships finally unloaded, attention has turned to selling the shipping company's assets.

"They've sold in the order of $40 million which is a very small part of overall debt of $8 billion," said shipping lawyer Ernie van Buuren, who represents a number of Australian businesses owed money by Hanjin.

"They're small amounts in terms of service providers like tug operators, pilots in Australia, to larger amounts running in to the millions of dollars," he said, adding that his clients are unlikely to see any of that money.

"They're not secured creditors which is part of the problem. Some of them are participating in the rehabilitation procedures in Korea at the moment."

"Whether they're likely to get money is still to be seen but it's not very optimistic."

Few buyers for Hanjin's ships in crowded market

There will be few buyers for Hanjin's ships as the global market is already oversupplied. Shipowners ordered new ships a decade ago when the market was strong, and they are still being delivered today.

At the same time there is less demand as the export of goods has declined, particularly as China's booming economy slows down.

Globally, shipping is an industry in consolidation.

In response to Hanjin's collapse, Japan's three biggest shippers, K line, MOL and NYK will merge their container businesses, and other smaller companies are likely to be swallowed up.

"The top 10 are really going to control about 77 to 80 per cent of world container fleet," said Mr van Buuren.

Australia's shipping industry is hollowing out as companies move their headquarters to Asia, where tax breaks and cheap labour are offered.

"There's been at least half a dozen move to Singapore, move their headquarters, offices, take their strategic decisions. Singapore has done that very successfully, there's an economic cluster for Singapore," said Ms Lloyd.

That has left Australian businesses that supply the shipping companies struggling and millions of dollars of business going offshore.

"There's manning, crewing, providoring, stewardship … lifeboat manufacturers, paint companies, the service industries that make sure the ship is at sea.

"When head office making those decisions is in Australia, it's good for Australian businesses," said Ms Lloyd.

No comments:

Post a Comment